Get the Right Insurance Policy for You
Same-Day Appointments | Family-Owned | Personal Attention
Same-Day Appointments
Family-Owned
Personal Attention
We search all our insurers to see if we can get you better coverage at a lower price.
Are you sure you’re covered?
Make sure you have the right coverage at the right price. We’ll find the best rates and uncover potential gaps in your current coverage. It’s a quick and easy way to have the peace of mind knowing your assets are protected in case of an unforeseen event.
Personalized Insurance Plans
Protect yourself, your loved ones and your property with an insurance policy from The Michael Davis Insurance Agency. We’ll go above and beyond to find the right personal insurance plan to fit your specific needs.
Automotive Insurance
It’s the law! Wisconsin drivers are required to carry auto insurance. The team of friendly professionals at The Michael Davis Insurance Agency will work with you to find the best auto insurance policy for you.
What if something happens to your home?
Your house is likely the biggest investment you’ll ever make. Does your insurance cover everything you would need to repair or replace? Finding dangerous gaps in your home insurance before a disaster is the only way to truly protect your family’s home.
Are you ready to start a quote?
The first step in working together is to review your current insurance information. Please click the link below to verify your insurance (takes 2 minutes).
Once you complete this process, I’ll be able to do the heavy lifting to find you the best available policy and we will be in touch to set up a review call.
We love our customers!
Check out these comments from our happy customers – and visit our Google business information page to see more.
Super pleased with my experience working with Michael! He was able to find way better options than our existing State Farm auto insurance! He is saving us a TON of money and also getting us WAY better coverage for less! I highly recommend you give him a call!
What an amazing experience! Michael was on top of finding me the best deal for my business as well as home insurance for my first home! Very impressed with the service and the care he gave my husband and myself! Thanks Michael!!
I was shopping for Insurance, and I called them after 5pm. Mr. Davis answered my call, and guided me through the best options for me. The next afternoon he had a quote ready and didnt pressure me to make my decision right away. I am very pleased with my decision to become part of his Insurance family. I HIGHLY reccomend Michael Davis Insurance Agency.
It has always been a positive experience dealing with Mike and his agency. He worked with my situation and was able to get a great rate on quality insurance. Mike responded very quickly to questions and is very knowledgeable. I highly recommend!
Since opening my business back in 2020, working with Michael Davis & his agency has been a absolute pleasure. He was able to find me the best rates for my company , all while making sure that plan was the best for me and my profession. He even went the extra mile to find me the best rate I’ve ever heard of for my car insurance as well! I highly recommend giving them a call today !
Prompt and courteous service along with follow up to make sure everything was what I needed for Homeowners insurance and also the offer to bundle car insurance. Very satisfied and highly recommend Michael Davis Insurance Agency for your insurance needs.
Comprehensive Coverage, Personalized Service
At The Michael Davis Agency, we work with multiple carriers to find you the right coverage at the best value. We specialize in securing discounts for educators, military members, and various professional groups—let us do the legwork while you enjoy the savings.
Personal Insurance
Whether you need protection for your home, vehicles, recreational toys, or want to ensure your family’s financial security with life insurance, we’ll help you find a policy that fits your unique needs.
Business Insurance
We partner with small businesses to provide essential coverage including General Liability, Commercial Property, Commercial Auto, Workers Compensation, and Directors & Officers insurance, along with other specialized coverages tailored to your industry.
Ready to explore your options? Let’s find the right protection for what matters most to you.
Meet Our Staff
Michael Davis
Laika Davis
Marlie DeCoster
Meet Kari Mooney
Since joining the team in early 2024, Kari has quickly become a vital part of Michael Davis Insurance Agency. For Kari, the best part of the job is the culture of honesty and care — values she is proud to pass on to every client she helps. She loves getting to know people and learning about their financial goals so she can protect what matters most to them.
Before becoming a licensed agent, Kari spent years in the financial sector. She holds an Accounting degree from Lakeland University and has worked as a township treasurer, a church accountant, and at a CPA firm. This experience gives her a sharp eye for detail when reviewing your policy coverage.
When she isn’t at the office, you can find Kari fishing, cruising in her Corvette, or working on a jigsaw puzzle. She lives with her husband, stepson, and a very spoiled cat. (Fun fact: She is also the reigning ping-pong champion of her household!)
Kari Mooney
Meet Tiffany Taff
As a fresh-faced insurance agent bursting into the world of risk management in late 2024, I’m on a mission to provide personally tailored policies, with a budget friendly price tag, and explaining their policy and its coverages in a down-to-earth relatable tone making it less boring and confusing. I understand that insurance isn’t just about policies, but protecting peoples dreams and livelihoods and I’m not just selling protection I’m building trust, one “what-if” at a time.
Having a modern-day insurance guru, Mr. Davis as my mentor, is like having a secret superpower! Having a personal tour guide, helping me navigate through the crazy world of insurance, he’s always willing and eager to pass on the massive amount of insurance knowledge he’s obtained through decades of experience in the industry.
When I’m not helping clients protect what matter most, you can find me enjoying the simple joys in life – hosting and dominating yard games in the summer sun with family and friends, when the winter comes so does my creative side; getting crafty with my Cricut or mastering yet another puzzle – a hobby that reflects my love for detail and creative problem solving.
My professional philosophy is simple: treat each clients insurance needs as I would my own, ensuring you’re covered without breaking the bank – because piece of mind shouldn’t cost a fortune. Whether it’s summer shenanigans or winter problem solving I bring creativity, passion, and a whole lot of personality to everything I do, with a side of humor and heart.
Tiffany Taff